What the hydrodynamic resistance is and why it matters

Sailing yacht reaching

The motion of a sailing yacht through water requires energy to overcome resistance, which is the force working against the movement. The resistance depends on the boat speed: the higher the velocity, the higher the resistance force. The resistance force is often referred to as drag force or simply drag.

The sails obtain from the wind the energy required to overcome the resistance. This energy is then made available to the boat through the rig. But the boat can only use a fraction of that energy in increasing its speed. The majority of the energy is lost in different mechanisms, each representing an individual resistance force that adds up to the total resistance experimented by the boat.

Each boat has its own characteristic resistance-speed curve. The thrust pushing the boat forward equates to the resistance force in a boat sailing at a constant speed. If the thrust exceeds the amount of resistance, the boat accelerates, but as the velocity increases, so does the resistance. Hence, the acceleration starts to decrease until it becomes null, and the yacht finds another point of equilibrium at a higher speed. When the resistance exceeds the thrust, the boat decelerates until it fully stops.

Considering everything else the same, a boat featuring a lower resistance-speed curve will require less thrust, i.e., less energy, to sail at the same speed than another with a higher curve.

Resistance-Speed curves for two yachts.
Yacht 1 needs more thrust (propulsion) to sail at the same speed than Yacht 2.

In other words, if both of these boats had the same amount of thrust, the one with a lower resistance would sail faster.

Resistance-Speed curves for two yachts.
For the same amount of thrust (propulsion) available, Yacht 2 can sail faster.

We call aerodynamic forces those generated by the interaction of the boat with the air or wind, while hydrodynamic forces are those created by interaction with the water. In a sailing yacht, aerodynamic forces are responsible for the thrust, and hydrodynamic forces are the main responsible for the resistance (although aerodynamic resistance, also known as windage, can not always be neglected, as it cannot be in high-performance craft).

But what are those individual resistance forces, and what are the mechanisms behind them?

The resistance forces opposing forward movement in a sailing yacht are typically broken down into:

  • viscous resistance forces;
  • wave-making resistance forces;
  • induced resistance force;
  • added resistance in waves;
  • propeller resistance.

Often, the resistance is also divided based on how it is measured. From this perspective, they are classified in:

  • resistance when the boat is sailing upright in calm water (viscous, wave-making, induced, and propeller resistance);
  • additional resistance when the boat is sailing heeled in calm water (viscous and wave-making);
  • additional resistance in waves;

It is essential to know the mechanisms behind the generation of the resistance and how the hull and appendage volumes, shapes, and profiles relate to it. This knowledge is very important so that we can make the resistance of a new design match the project’s overall performance goals. In the following, we will take a look at how the resistance is created.

Viscous resistance

The viscous resistance forces are due to the viscosity of the water and are the most important resistance forces at low speed. The viscous resistance is further divided into:

  • Frictional resistance: as the boat moves, it loses energy overcoming the forces that tie together the molecules of water surrounding the hull and creating the eddies it leaves behind (see “Calculate the frictional resistance of the hull“). This phenomenon happens in the boundary layer, where two zones with distinct types of flows are observed: laminar and turbulent.
  • Pressure resistance: as the hull makes its way through the water, the water pressure over the bow is higher than its pressure over the stern. This pressure imbalance translates into a net force acting against the yacht forward movement. Besides the boundary layer, the pressure resistance also depends on the hull’s shape and profile; hence, it is also known as form drag.

Wave-making resistance

The wave-making resistance, or wave resistance, is due to the waves a boat creates as it moves.

Sailing yachts move through the air-water interface, where two different fluids of two very different densities, air, and water, enter into contact. As the boat moves, it modifies the water’s speed and pressure around it, producing a variation on the water level (the air’s weight cannot compensate for it), which generates a wave system that travels together with the boat. Developing and maintaining this wave system requires a constant input of energy from the boat. Thus, instead of being used in increasing the speed, a part of the energy obtained by the sails is lost.

Bow and stern waves of a boat sailing in calm water.

At low speed, the wave-making resistance is small compared with the viscous resistance. However, as the yacht speed increases, it becomes more and more important until it grows into the most important component of the total resistance.

The pressure resistance part of the viscous resistance and the wave-making resistance are often considered together under the term residuary resistance. After measuring the total resistance in a test tank, the frictional resistance, which can be calculated with a formula developed for a flat plate corrected for the three-dimensional case, is subtracted. What is left, the “residuary,” corresponds to the viscous and wave-making resistance (assuming the test has been conducted in calm water and without leeway).

Relative weight of the Frictional and Residuary resistance of a boat at low speed.
Frictional and residuary resistance of a boat at high speed.
Relative weight of the Frictional and Residuary resistance of a boat at high speed.

The English engineer William Froude was the first to understand how a moving hull creates a wave system and how this phenomenon causes resistance to motion.

Induced resistance

When a yacht sails upwind, the wind pushes the boat away, making it drift leeward. The yacht moves with a leeway angle, and the incoming water attacks the boat (hull, keel, and rudder) at a certain angle of incidence. Under these conditions, the speed profile of the water at the proximity of the boat changes, decreasing the pressure on the windward side of the submerged parts and increasing the pressure on the leeward side.

This difference of pressure makes a portion of the water on the leeward side (higher pressure) flow to the windward side (lower pressure) below the bottom tip of the hull, keel, and rudder, leaving behind vortices which contain rotational energy extracted from the boat, and therefore slowing it down. This phenomenon is especially important at the keel and rudder, where the local pressure changes abruptly, from higher to lower, at their sharp bottom tips.

It is essential to understand that when sailing upwind, the wind pushes the boat away, gradually increasing the attack angle between the water and the boat. In boats featuring keels or centerboards, as the angle increases, so does the induced resistance but also the value of a force called lift, which counters (opposes) the drifting force. Eventually, the drifting force and the lift force will be of the same value (if it does not stall before), and as they act in opposite directions, they will be canceled. At that moment, the boat will be able to sail windward at a constant leeway angle without drifting more. The lift force and the induced resistance (or drag) are intimately interrelated. Without one, there is not the other. Therefore, a certain amount of induced resistance will always be necessary for a boat to be capable of sailing upwind.

Added resistance in waves

A yacht that encounters waves while sailing, e.g., wind-generated waves, will see a reduction in its speed. In other words, the waves develop an additional resistance that opposes the boat’s forward motion. This resistance is known as the added resistance in waves.

The two main mechanisms by which this additional resistance is developed are:

  • the creation of additional waves by the boat as it heaves and pitches;
  • the additional induced resistance created at the tip of the keel, rudder, and hull as the boat rolls.

Tests have found that the additional induced resistance due to the rolling motion is probably not very large compared to the first mechanism. Therefore only the creation of waves is usually considered.

When a boat is heaving and pitching in a seaway, it generates additional waves that are propagated in all directions from the boat. These waves are superimposed to the wave system of the wave-making resistance. The creation of these additional waves needs energy, which can only be obtained from the energy made available by the sails, thus reducing the energy available for increasing the boat’s speed.

Heave and pitch movements of a boat in a seaway.

The characteristics of the encountered sea waves (wavelength and frequency) and the geometrical characteristics and mass distribution of the boat play fundamental roles in the added resistance in waves.

Propeller resistance

A sailing boat fitted with a propeller develops further resistance when sailing. The propeller creates viscous (frictional and pressure resistance) and induced (due to the propeller blades) resistance, especially when the propeller is blocked (not free to rotate) so to reduce wear on the shaft, the gearbox, and the bearings.

Do you want to read more articles like this?

See also:

References:

Some of the links shown below are affiliate links and we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you:

Send us a Message

    Related Articles

    The evolution of hull and keel forms – Part 2

    British “plank-on-edge” suffered from poor form stability. Yet, the deep down located ballast offered a considerable amount of weight stability and positive stability range. These boats rarely capsized, and if so, they didn’t remain in that position for a long time. American “skimming dishes” featured higher initial stability. Nevertheless, once the heeling angle exceeded 30 degrees, the yacht was prone to capsize, and if so, it was unable to come back upright. These yachts, although fast in light winds, were unsuitable for cruising.

    Surface waves

    Surface waves are created by disturbance forces applied to a specific area. It can be either the wind, a surface vessel moving through the water, an earthquake, landslides, a splash, gravity (as it is the case for tides), or any combination of them. When studying ocean waves, we consider them to be the superimposition of single sinusoidal waves with different frequencies and amplitudes.

    The lines drawing: what it is and how to read it

    The lines drawing or lines plan is the conventional graphical representation of the hull. Besides the hull, it sometimes also includes the keel and the rudder/s. In the lines drawing, the hull’s shape is represented by three different views, which can be considered the projection of the hull onto three orthogonal planes: the Profile Plan, the Body Plan, and the Plan (or Half-breadth Plan).

    What is the Froude number?

    The Froude number is a dimensionless number used to quantify the influence of gravity on the motion of a fluid. It is the ratio of the inertia forces to the gravitational forces related to the mass of water displaced by a floating boat.

    The air-water interface

    Water and air are two different fluids that enter into contact at the ocean’s surface at what is called the air-water interface. This interface plays an important role in ship hydrostatics and in describing the flow of water around a vessel.

    Introducing the hull

    The hull provides a volume to house accommodation, machinery, supplies, and cargo. It has to be seaworthy enough for the routes the yacht will sail and provide the lowest possible resistance to forward movement. It has to resist the heeling forces generated by the wind’s interaction with the sails and have a large resistance to sideways movement to reduce the sideways drift to leeward of the desired course. The hull determines most of the yachts’ main attributes: stability, resistance, seaworthiness, maneuverability, and load-carrying capacity.

    Responses