Challenges in sailboat design

Using wind power and sails as the primary means of propulsion brings additional dimensions to the design of a sailboat compared to ship or powerboat design. The designer’s challenge is to balance the different parameters to achieve the best overall performance and characteristics, rather than optimize the boat to one operating situation. This is one fundamental difference between ship design and leisure boat design.

Leisure boat design versus ship design

Ships typically have a reasonably well-defined task to perform and certain routes to sail. For example, they transfer passengers and lorries over the English channel, transport containers between Antwerp and Finland, or carry crude oil from the Persian Gulf to Rotterdam. The design office shall optimize the vessel effectiveness for that task, taking into account the restrictions of the harbors, waterways, and IMO (International Marine Organization) rules. The task may also include optimization of the transport efficiency of a whole fleet of ships. Multi-purpose ships like offshore supply vessels or workboats have several operational situations to be considered, but they are still limited and clearly specified.

Leisure boats shall offer their users a platform to enjoy outdoor life at sea or inland waters. This may include getting to islands or other harbors, fishing, bathing, swimming, diving, water-skiing, or other activities. This kind of use is typical for small powerboats. Usually, the designer’s task is not to optimize the boat to a specific loading condition or speed but to create a versatile platform suitable for several different applications. Requirements for the number of persons, speed range, and comfort level may vary a lot according to the day’s activity.

Use profiles of larger powerboats and sailing yachts, intended for cruising and overnighting, are more defined. At least the variation in loading conditions is narrower than in small powerboats because the own mass of the boat is proportionally larger. Nevertheless, the uses of bigger boats may still vary a lot, from short-distance dinner cruising or weekend overnighting in marinas to extended voyages that require large self-sufficiency. The dual-use possibility of sailing yachts as cruisers and racers is also important for many sailors, and that requires compromises between performance and comfort. Maybe small racing dinghies have the most precise task: have fun and win races.

Differences between sailing boats and powerboats design

There are some basic differences in the design aspects of sailing boats and powerboats, especially in performance prediction.

Powerboat design

At least until now, engine power and fuel price have not been really limiting factors for powerboat speed, which means that planning boats are popular, and hull resistance optimization has not been on the top of the designer’s mind. This may change in the future.

Apart from hull resistance optimization, other hydrodynamic aspects are also important, especially as the speed increases: comfort in a seaway, avoiding cavitation and instabilities like porpoising or chine walking, and safe maneuverability. Stability, buoyancy, and strength calculations should, of course, be high on the designer’s list, as high as the appearance, style, and interior ergonomy.

Sailing boat design

While powerboats have plenty of propulsive power available, sailboats have a constant shortage of forwarding driving force or thrust. So, minimizing the resistance is essential.

The side forces implied by the wind make this more complicated. The only exemption is running downwind in heavy weather. At all other points of sail, the wind is acting more or less from one side and creates an aerodynamic side force. Compared with the driving force, the side force is large, especially when sailing upwind. As the side force acts on the sails high up above the waterline, it produces a heeling moment. To counteract this, the sailing craft needs to have a similar amount of righting moment. The heeling angle increases until the boat provides enough stabilizing moment (sometimes helped by shifting weights like persons or ballast).

Also, the aerodynamic side force tries to push a sailing boat sideways. To counterbalance this force, a sailboat has to generate hydrodynamic side force in the opposite direction. With symmetric foils and hulls, a (small) leeway angle is needed for that purpose.

Unfortunately, both heeling and leeway angle generally increase the resistance of the hull. So, large stability preventing the boat from heeling too much, and effective appendages to keep leeway angle small are the key to improve upwind performance.

Safety and ergonomy of sailing boats

Enough stability is needed for the ability to sail upwind, but in extreme situations, good stability is needed to prevent capsizing. In large breaking waves, the extensive range of positive stability has been found to be the main safety factor for monohull sailing yachts. Multihulls, that inherently have high initial stability but lower angle of capsize, shall have a high value of righting moment area.

Ergonomy is also affecting the safe and effective use of sailing boats. While rolling motions and high vertical accelerations limit the comfort of powerboats in a seaway, it is mostly the constant heeling angle of monohulled sailboats that makes life onboard difficult. Although the angle is not more than 15-20 degrees, it can be challenging to move around on deck and in the cabin. Locating winches, sheets, halyards, and control lines in a proper way makes their use both safer and more effective. This means that deck organizing may also affect sailboat performance.

Do you want to read more articles like this?

See also:

More info:

Some of the links shown below are affiliate links and we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you:

Send us a Message

    Related Articles

    What is the Froude number?

    The Froude number is a dimensionless number used to quantify the influence of gravity on the motion of a fluid. It is the ratio of the inertia forces to the gravitational forces related to the mass of water displaced by a floating boat.

    The evolution of hull and keel forms – Part 1

    Until the 19th century, the art of yacht design had been mainly influenced by tradition, economic and commercial motivations, understanding of materials and their availability, and genuine or semi-scientific developments in hydro and aerodynamics. Boats had been evolved through a long but reliable process of trial and error. But now, rating rules, which most of them had nothing to do with real scientific knowledge, started to play a significant role in hull design on both sides of the Atlantic.

    The evolution of hull and keel forms – Part 2

    British “plank-on-edge” suffered from poor form stability. Yet, the deep down located ballast offered a considerable amount of weight stability and positive stability range. These boats rarely capsized, and if so, they didn’t remain in that position for a long time. American “skimming dishes” featured higher initial stability. Nevertheless, once the heeling angle exceeded 30 degrees, the yacht was prone to capsize, and if so, it was unable to come back upright. These yachts, although fast in light winds, were unsuitable for cruising.

    Added resistance in waves: “Pinkster” solver versus “Keuning 2006” comparison

    In 1980, Johannes Albert Pinkster defended his doctoral thesis “Low frequency second order wave exciting forces on floating structures”. His work focused on how these forces acted on stationary vessels in regular and irregular waves and developed a method to predict them. His method can also be used to predict the additional resistance in waves experienced by a ship by adjusting the frequency of encounter of the waves.
    Twenty-six years later, in 2006, Jan Alexander Keuning et al. presented the paper “An Approximation Method for the Added Resistance in Waves of a Sailing Yacht,” which aimed to develop a calculation method for the assessment of the added resistance of a sailing yacht when sailing in waves. Their approach uses a polynomial expression that considers the primary design parameters of interest as far as added resistance in waves is concerned.
    Jean-Francois MASSET compares these both methods developed at TU Delft by applying them to a day-boat project and analyzing the results.